From Data to Dollars: The 10 Metrics Every Fundraiser Needs

In this episode of Let's Talk Fundraising, we’re diving deep into the world of fundraising metrics. Join me, Keith Greer, CFRE, as we explore the top 10 metrics that can transform your nonprofit’s fundraising strategy from good to great.

We'll start with a captivating story from a small Sicilian village that learned the power of understanding their supporters, and then break down each essential metric: from Cost Per Dollar Raised and Donation Revenue Growth Rate to Average Gift Size and Donor Retention Rate. These metrics aren’t just numbers; they’re the heartbeat of your organization, guiding you toward more effective strategies and stronger donor relationships.

Plus, stick around for a special bonus metric on Visitation and Engagement Metrics, crucial for major gift fundraising success. By the end of this episode, you’ll have a comprehensive toolkit to refine your strategies, improve your outcomes, and ultimately make a bigger impact.

Tune in, take notes, and get ready to elevate your fundraising game!

Ready to transform your nonprofit’s content creation? AI Powered Copywriter is your answer! Discover how to build a custom GPT that reflects your nonprofit’s unique voice—no more generic, uninspired AI copy. Imagine saving hours each week with a tool that drafts heartfelt donor letters, compelling social posts, and consistent, mission-driven messaging in seconds. 

Transcript

Hey there, hi, and welcome, Ambitious Fundraisers! It's great to have you back for another episode of Let's Talk Fundraising, where we dive into the nitty-gritty of what makes our nonprofit world tick. I'm Keith Greer, and today, we're diving deep into the 10 most important fundraising metrics and why they matter. But first, let me tell you a story—picture it: Sicily, 1922...

A tiny village nestled between rolling hills and olive groves. There was a local group, "Questo è Inventato," dedicated to helping orphaned children. They had hearts of gold but struggled to keep their doors open. Funds were tight, and the local bake sales and festivals just weren't cutting it anymore.

One day, a wise old woman, Nonna Rosa suggested they take a different approach. "We need to understand our supporters better," she said, "so we know what makes them tick." The group was puzzled, but they trusted Nonna Rosa's wisdom.

Nonna Rosa taught them to track important information—how many people came back to support them year after year, how many new faces they saw, and how much each person gave. They started writing down everything, from the smallest lira to the largest gold coin. They even started sending thank-you notes and updates to show their appreciation.

As they gathered this information, patterns emerged. They realized that while they were great at attracting new donors during their lively festivals, they weren’t doing enough to keep them coming back. So, they made a plan. They held special appreciation dinners, sent handwritten notes, and shared stories about the children whose lives were being changed.

Slowly but surely, the donations started to grow. People felt more connected, more appreciated, and they gave more generously. Questo è Inventato didn't just survive; they flourished. They built new dormitories, bought more supplies, and even started a scholarship fund.

And you see, that's the power of understanding your fundraising metrics. Just like in that little Sicilian village, these numbers aren’t just numbers; they’re the heartbeat of your organization, guiding you toward more effective strategies and stronger donor relationships. So, let’s jump right in and explore these essential metrics together! Let’s Talk Fundraising.

 Now, starting with the big one at number ten on our countdown of crucial fundraising metrics, we have...

 Cost Per Dollar Raised! Also known as CPDR, this metric is all about understanding the cost efficiency of your fundraising activities. In other words, it tells you how much it costs to bring in every single dollar of donations. Now, I know this might sound a bit like accounting 101, but stick with me because this is where the magic happens.

 Imagine planning a grand fundraising gala. There’s the venue, the catering, the entertainment, the marketing—everything adds up. After all those expenses, you tally up the total amount of donations that came in. 

 The CPDR metric is your guide to evaluating whether that gala, or any other fundraising effort, was worth the investment. It gives you a clear picture of how much you spent to raise each dollar. This insight is golden because it helps you make informed decisions about where to allocate your resources. If you find that it costs fifty cents to raise a dollar, you might be onto something efficient. But if it's costing you two dollars to raise one, well, that's a sign that something needs to be reevaluated.

Let me paint a clearer picture for you. Imagine running a direct mail campaign. You spend a thousand dollars on printing, postage, and design. When all is said and done, you raise two thousand dollars. That might sound great at first glance, right? But when you break it down, you’re spending fifty cents for every dollar raised. Now, compare that to a different campaign where you spend the same thousand dollars but only raise five hundred dollars. Here, you're spending two dollars to bring in just one dollar. 

Understanding this ratio helps you measure the financial efficiency of your campaigns. It’s like having a financial compass that points you toward the most cost-effective strategies. And trust me, your board and donors will appreciate knowing that you’re not just throwing money around but making every penny count.

This metric also comes in handy when planning future events or campaigns. By looking at past CPDRs, you can identify which types of fundraising activities are worth repeating and which ones might need a different approach or even to be scrapped entirely. It’s about working smarter, not harder. 

So, the next time you’re planning an event, a campaign, or even just brainstorming new fundraising ideas, remember to keep an eye on your CPDR. It’s not just a number; it’s a powerful tool that ensures you’re making the most of your resources and maximizing your impact. And as we all know, every dollar raised is a step closer to fulfilling your mission and making a difference.

Alright, let's continue our countdown with number nine on our list of essential fundraising metrics: Fundraising Return on Investment, or ROI. This metric is all about measuring the efficiency of your fundraising efforts by comparing the amount raised to the cost of fundraising.

So, what exactly is Fundraising ROI? It’s a way to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of different fundraising strategies by looking at the return generated relative to the investment made. Think of it as seeing how much bang you’re getting for your buck. If you’re spending money on a fundraising campaign, you want to know if the returns justify the costs.

Why is this important? Fundraising ROI helps you understand the overall effectiveness of your fundraising efforts. It gives you a clear picture of which strategies are working best and which ones might need some tweaking. By focusing on ROI, you can make more informed decisions about where to allocate your resources to maximize your impact.

Let’s break this down with an example. Imagine your organization runs a fundraising campaign that raises $100,000 but costs $20,000 to execute. To calculate your Fundraising ROI, you subtract the total cost of fundraising from the total funds raised, giving you $80,000. Then, you divide that by the total cost of fundraising, which is $20,000, and multiply by 100. In this case, your ROI would be 400%. This means that for every dollar spent, you’re generating four dollars in return.

Now, you might be wondering how this differs from our #10, Cost Per Dollar Raised, or CPDR. Both metrics are crucial, but they offer different perspectives. CPDR focuses on the cost aspect, showing how much is spent to raise each dollar. In contrast, ROI focuses on the return, showing how much is gained relative to the investment. With CPDR, a lower number is better because it indicates less spent per dollar raised. For ROI, a higher number is better, indicating a greater return on the investment. 

Another key difference is in how they are calculated. CPDR is calculated by dividing total fundraising expenses by total funds raised. ROI, on the other hand, involves subtracting expenses from revenue before dividing. This means that CPDR gives you a straightforward look at cost efficiency, while ROI provides a broader view of overall effectiveness. 

CPDR is often used to evaluate the efficiency of specific fundraising methods or campaigns, while ROI provides a broader view of overall fundraising effectiveness. CPDR is typically expressed in dollars and cents, while ROI is usually presented as a percentage or ratio. 

Understanding these key differences can help you use both metrics effectively. While CPDR can pinpoint the efficiency of individual campaigns, ROI gives you a big-picture view of your overall fundraising health. By tracking both, you can ensure that you’re not only raising funds efficiently but also making smart investments that yield the highest returns.

So, as you plan your next fundraising efforts, keep a close eye on your Fundraising ROI. It’s more than just a number; it’s a powerful tool that guides you in making strategic decisions, ensuring that every dollar spent is driving the most significant impact possible.

Next up at number eight on our list of essential fundraising metrics is Donation Revenue Growth Rate. Now, this one’s a bit like watching your nonprofit’s financial health grow and flourish over time.

So, what exactly is the Donation Revenue Growth Rate? It’s all about tracking the change in your donation revenue over a specific period, typically year over year. This metric gives you a clear picture of whether your fundraising efforts are heading in the right direction or if you need to pivot your strategies.

Think of it like watching a garden. If you planted seeds last year and this year you see more flowers blooming, you know you’re doing something right. Similarly, if your current year's revenue is higher than last year's, it means your fundraising garden is thriving. But if the growth is stagnant or declining, it's a signal to review your methods.

Now, why is this important? The Donation Revenue Growth Rate provides valuable insights into the overall growth of your fundraising efforts. It tells you if your strategies are working, if your donor base is expanding, and if your engagement tactics are effective. It’s a straightforward way to measure progress and celebrate the wins, no matter how small they might seem.

Let’s break it down with an example. Say last year your organization raised $100,000, and this year you’ve raised $120,000. You’d subtract the previous year’s revenue from the current year’s, giving you $20,000. Then, you divide that by the previous year’s revenue—$100,000—and multiply by 100 to get your growth rate. In this case, you’re looking at a 20% growth rate. That’s a strong indicator that you’re on the right path and your efforts are paying off.

 This metric is particularly useful when presenting to your board or stakeholders. It gives them a clear, quantifiable measure of your success and helps build confidence in your strategies. Plus, it’s a great motivator for your team. Seeing tangible growth can boost morale and drive everyone to keep pushing forward.

But what if the numbers aren’t as rosy? A negative growth rate isn’t the end of the world. It’s an opportunity to dig deeper and understand what might be causing the decline. Are there external factors at play? Have there been changes in donor behavior? Maybe your messaging needs a refresh, or perhaps it’s time to explore new fundraising channels. The key is to use this metric as a diagnostic tool, helping you refine and improve your approach.

So, keep an eye on your Donation Revenue Growth Rate. It’s not just about numbers; it’s about understanding the story they tell and using that story to guide your next steps. Growth is a journey, and every bit of progress counts.

Coming in at number seven, we’ve got another crucial metric to discuss—Average Gift Size and its often overlooked sibling, Median Gift Size. These metrics are like peeking into the heart of donor generosity and understanding the value behind each donation.

So, what exactly is Average Gift Size? It’s the average amount of money that your donors are giving per donation. Think of it as taking all the individual gifts you’ve received and figuring out what the middle ground looks like. To find the Average Gift Size, you simply divide the total donation amount by the number of donations. For example, if over the course of a year your organization received a total of $50,000 in donations from 500 gifts, you divide $50,000 by 500, giving you an average gift size of $100.

Now, let's talk about Median Gift Size. This is the middle value in your list of donations, meaning half of your gifts are above this amount, and half are below. To find the Median Gift Size, you need to list all your donations in numerical order and find the middle point. If you have an odd number of donations, it’s the middle one. If you have an even number, it’s the average of the two middle numbers.

Why are these metrics important? Understanding both Average and Median Gift Sizes helps you get a comprehensive view of donor behavior. The Average Gift Size gives you a general sense of how generous your donors are on average. It’s essential for setting realistic fundraising goals and creating strategies to engage your donors. However, the average can be skewed by a few very large or very small donations.

That’s where Median Gift Size comes in. It gives you a clearer picture of what a typical donation looks like by minimizing the impact of outliers. For instance, if you receive a few large gifts that significantly raise the average, the median will show you that the majority of your donors are giving a different amount.

Let’s break this down with an example, and if you want to follow along mathematically this is a good time to pause and grab a pen and paper to take some notes. Say your donations for the year are as follows: $10, $20, $30, $40, $50, $1,000. The average would be calculated by adding these amounts ($1,150) and dividing by the number of donations (6), giving you an average gift size of about $191. But the median gift size, the middle number when the donations are listed in order, is $35. This shows that while your average is skewed by that one large donation, most of your donors are giving around $35.

Knowing both your Average and Median Gift Sizes can influence how you engage with your donors. If your average gift size is high, it suggests strong donor generosity, which might indicate a deep connection to your cause. This insight can help you tailor your communication strategies to nurture these relationships further. Personalized thank-you notes, special updates, and exclusive event invitations are great ways to keep these donors engaged and appreciated.

On the other hand, if your Median Gift Size is lower, it tells you what most donors are giving and can help you strategize ways to encourage higher giving. Sharing impactful stories, demonstrating tangible outcomes of donations, or creating matching gift opportunities can inspire larger gifts.

 These metrics also play a crucial role in donor segmentation. By understanding both averages, you can segment your donors into different categories—small, medium, and large gift givers—and tailor your messaging accordingly. High-value donors might appreciate detailed reports on how their contributions are making a difference, while smaller donors might be encouraged by stories of collective impact and how every bit helps.

Let’s not forget the role of these metrics in setting fundraising goals. If you’re planning a campaign, knowing your Average and Median Gift Sizes can help you estimate how many donations you’ll need to reach your target. It’s all about being strategic and informed, making every effort count.

So, as you look at your fundraising data, keep a keen eye on both your Average and Median Gift Sizes. They’re more than just numbers; they’re windows into donor behavior and tools to enhance your fundraising strategies.

Alright, Ambitious Fundraisers, let's keep the countdown going! At number six, we have a metric that’s all about the hustle and heart of your fundraising efforts: Asks Made. This one’s all about the number of direct requests for contributions made to a given donor or group of donors.

So, what exactly do we mean by Asks Made? Simply put, it’s the number of times you’ve directly asked donors for contributions. This could be through face-to-face meetings, phone calls, emails, letters, or even at events. Essentially, any time you’re making a direct appeal for donations, it counts as an ask.

Why is this important? Tracking Asks Made provides insight into how proactive and aggressive your fundraising efforts are. It’s a vital metric for evaluating the effectiveness of your solicitation strategies. If you’re seeing a strong correlation between the number of asks and the donations received, it’s a good indicator that your approach is working.

Let’s break this down with an example. Imagine you’re working on a major gift campaign. You’ve identified a group of potential donors and planned to make a direct appeal to each one. By tracking the number of Asks Made, you can see how many times you’ve reached out and compare that to the number of donations received. This helps you understand not just the quantity but the quality of your efforts.

For instance, if you’ve made 50 asks and received 30 donations, you have a 60% success rate. But if you’ve made 50 asks and only received 10 donations, it might be time to re-evaluate your approach. Are your messages resonating? Are you reaching out through the right channels? Are you engaging with the donors in a way that aligns with their interests and values?

Understanding Asks Made is especially crucial in major gift fundraising. These are high-stakes asks, often involving significant preparation and personalized engagement. Keeping track of how many asks you’re making can help you manage your efforts and ensure you’re giving each potential donor the attention they deserve.

Moreover, this metric helps in setting realistic goals for your team. If you know that, on average, you need to make 10 asks to secure one major gift, you can plan your activities accordingly. It’s about working smart and setting yourself up for success.

But don’t just stop at the numbers. Reflect on the quality of your asks. Are you telling compelling stories? Are you clearly articulating the impact of a potential gift? Are you following up and showing appreciation regardless of the outcome? The effectiveness of your asks isn’t just about quantity; it’s also about how well you’re connecting with your donors.

So, as you strategize your next campaign, keep a close eye on the Asks Made. It’s a metric that keeps you grounded in the reality of your efforts and provides a roadmap for where you can improve. Remember, every ask is an opportunity to build a relationship, tell your story, and bring in the support you need to make a difference.

Let's jump right back in! At number five on our list of essential fundraising metrics is Major Gifts Secured. This metric is like the crown jewel in your fundraising efforts, giving you clear insight into the number and value of large donations received.

So, what do we mean by Major Gifts Secured? This metric tracks both the quantity and the total value of those significant donations that have the power to make a substantial impact on your organization. These are the big gifts, the ones that often come from major donors who believe deeply in your mission and are willing to invest significantly in your cause.

Why is this important? Major gifts are critical for meeting your fundraising goals. They can often make up a significant portion of your total revenue and can be game-changers in terms of funding key programs, initiatives, or capital projects. Understanding how many major gifts you’re securing, and their total value, helps you gauge the success of your major gift campaigns and the effectiveness of your major donor engagement strategies.

 Let’s break it down with an example. Imagine over the course of a year, your organization has received ten major gifts, each valued at $50,000. This would mean you’ve secured a total of $500,000 from major gifts. This information is powerful because it tells you not just about the generosity of individual donors but also about the strength of your relationships and the effectiveness of your fundraising strategies.

To calculate this metric, you simply tally the number of major gifts received and their total value. It’s straightforward but incredibly telling. If you’re seeing a good number of high-value gifts coming in, it’s a sign that your major gift strategies are working well. But if you’re not seeing as many as you’d like, it might be time to review your approach.

Understanding Major Gifts Secured is crucial for several reasons. First, it helps you identify trends and patterns in donor behavior. Are certain times of the year more fruitful for securing major gifts? Are there particular campaigns or events that tend to bring in larger donations? This insight can help you plan and strategize more effectively.

Second, this metric is a strong indicator of your organization’s ability to cultivate and maintain relationships with major donors. Major gifts don’t just happen overnight; they’re the result of building trust, demonstrating impact, and engaging donors in meaningful ways. By tracking this metric, you can assess how well you’re doing in these areas and identify opportunities for improvement.

Finally, Major Gifts Secured can play a pivotal role in your overall fundraising strategy. Knowing how much you can count on from major gifts allows you to set more realistic goals, plan your budget more accurately, and allocate resources more effectively. It’s about having a clear picture of where your significant funding is coming from and ensuring you’re doing everything you can to maximize this crucial revenue stream.

So, as you continue your fundraising journey, keep a close eye on Major Gifts Secured. It’s more than just a number; it’s a testament to the strength of your relationships and the impact of your efforts. Every major gift is a vote of confidence in your mission and a step closer to achieving your goals.

Now, next up at number four on our list of essential fundraising metrics: Recurring Gift Percentage. This metric tells you how many of your total gifts for a given time period were part of donors’ recurring gift schedules. Understanding this percentage can give you a solid baseline for recurring gift campaigns and provide insights into expected funds in the future, even though these funds can’t be officially accounted for in next year’s annual budget.

So, what does Recurring Gift Percentage really mean? It’s about knowing how much of your donation pool is coming from regular, ongoing contributions versus one-time gifts. This metric is crucial because recurring gifts often represent a more stable and predictable income stream. Donors who commit to giving regularly are typically more engaged and invested in your cause, which can translate into long-term support and higher lifetime value.

Let’s dive into how to calculate this KPI. To find your Recurring Gift Percentage, you divide the number of recurring gifts by the total number of gifts, then multiply by 100 to get a percentage. It’s a straightforward calculation but packed with valuable insights.

Here’s an example. Suppose your organization received 3,000 donations in a given year, and 600 of those were recurring gifts. To find the Recurring Gift Percentage, you divide 600 by 3,000, which equals 0.2. Multiply that by 100, and you get 20%. So, your recurring gift percentage is 20%.

Understanding this metric is essential for several reasons. First, it helps you gauge the success of your recurring gift programs. A higher percentage means that a significant portion of your donors are committed to giving regularly, which is a fantastic indicator of donor loyalty and engagement. Second, it provides a sense of financial stability. Knowing that a portion of your revenue is coming from reliable, recurring sources can help you plan better and allocate resources more effectively.

Moreover, focusing on increasing your Recurring Gift Percentage can have long-term benefits. Recurring donors often give more over time compared to one-time donors, and they’re more likely to become major donors in the future. By nurturing these relationships, you’re building a robust foundation for your organization’s financial health.

So, as you analyze your fundraising efforts, keep a close eye on your Recurring Gift Percentage. It’s more than just a number; it’s a reflection of donor commitment and a key indicator of financial stability. By understanding and leveraging this metric, you can enhance your fundraising strategies and ensure a steady stream of support for your mission.

 Coming in at number three on our countdown of essential fundraising metrics is Lifetime Donor Value, or LTV. This metric is like the golden nugget of donor data, measuring the total amount a donor is anticipated to contribute over their lifetime with your organization.

So, what exactly is Lifetime Donor Value? It’s a comprehensive look at the long-term value of your donor relationships. Rather than just focusing on one-time gifts or short-term contributions, LTV helps you understand the cumulative impact of a donor’s support over many years.

Why is this important? Assessing the long-term value of donor relationships is crucial for guiding your investment in donor retention and engagement. When you know the potential value of a donor over their lifetime, you can make more informed decisions about where to allocate resources and how to cultivate lasting relationships. It's all about thinking long-term and recognizing that the real value of a donor goes beyond their initial gift.

Let’s break down how to calculate this metric. To find your LTV, you multiply three key figures: the average donation amount, the average number of donations per year, and the average donor lifespan. 

Here’s an example to bring it to life. Suppose the average donation amount from a donor is $100, they donate three times a year on average, and their average lifespan as a donor with your organization is ten years. To calculate the LTV, you multiply these figures together: $100 times 3 times 10, which gives you $3,000. So, the Lifetime Donor Value for an average donor is $3,000.

Understanding LTV is powerful for several reasons. First, it helps you appreciate the full value of your donor relationships. When you see that a donor’s lifetime value is significantly higher than their initial gift, it underscores the importance of ongoing engagement and retention efforts. It’s a reminder that every touchpoint, thank-you note, and update plays a role in nurturing these valuable relationships.

Second, LTV can guide your donor acquisition and retention strategies. Knowing that a donor’s potential lifetime value is substantial can justify the upfront costs of acquiring and engaging donors. It also highlights the importance of investing in personalized communication and stewardship efforts to keep donors connected and committed to your cause.

Lastly, focusing on LTV can shift your organization’s mindset from short-term fundraising goals to long-term relationship building. It’s about fostering loyalty and creating a community of supporters who are with you for the long haul. This approach not only enhances your financial stability but also builds a stronger, more engaged donor base.

So, as you plan your fundraising strategies, keep a close eye on your Lifetime Donor Value. It’s more than just a metric; it’s a testament to the enduring impact of donor relationships and a guide for making strategic decisions that ensure lasting support for your mission.

Almost at the top of our list, coming in at number two, we have the Donor Acquisition Rate. This metric tracks the number of new donors acquired over a specific period, giving you insights into how well your outreach and marketing efforts are working.

So, what exactly is Donor Acquisition Rate? It’s a way to measure how effective you are at bringing new supporters into your fold. Whether you’re running a social media campaign, hosting events, or sending out email appeals, this metric tells you how successful those efforts are at attracting fresh faces to your cause.

Why is this important? Understanding your Donor Acquisition Rate helps you gauge the effectiveness of your outreach strategies. It gives you a clear picture of how well you’re expanding your donor base, which is crucial for the long-term growth and sustainability of your organization. New donors are the lifeblood of your fundraising efforts—they bring fresh energy, new perspectives, and, of course, additional financial support.

Let’s break down how to calculate this metric. To find your Donor Acquisition Rate, you divide the number of new donors by the total number of donors for a given period, then multiply by 100 to get a percentage.

Here’s an example to illustrate. Suppose you gained 200 new donors last year, and your total number of donors for that year was 1,000. To calculate the Donor Acquisition Rate, you divide 200 by 1,000, which equals 0.2. Multiply that by 100, and you get a 20% acquisition rate. This means 20% of your donors were new that year.

Tracking this metric is powerful for several reasons. First, it provides direct feedback on your marketing and outreach efforts. If your acquisition rate is high, it’s a sign that your strategies are resonating with potential donors. Conversely, if the rate is lower than expected, it might be time to rethink your approach or try new channels.

Second, a healthy Donor Acquisition Rate is essential for balancing out donor attrition. Even with excellent retention strategies, you’ll inevitably lose some donors each year. Bringing in new donors ensures that your overall donor base continues to grow, offsetting those losses and driving your mission forward.

Lastly, focusing on donor acquisition can lead to innovative and engaging campaigns. When you’re actively trying to attract new supporters, you’re more likely to experiment with different tactics, from creative social media campaigns to compelling storytelling in your appeals. This not only helps bring in new donors but can also re-energize your existing donor base.

So, as you plan your fundraising and marketing strategies, keep a close eye on your Donor Acquisition Rate. It’s more than just a number; it’s a key indicator of your organization’s ability to grow and thrive. By understanding and leveraging this metric, you can ensure that your outreach efforts are effective and that you’re continually bringing new supporters into your community.

We’ve finally reached the top spot on our countdown of essential fundraising metrics. Coming in at number one is Donor Retention Rate. This metric measures the percentage of donors who continue to give to your organization year after year, and it’s absolutely crucial for the health and sustainability of your nonprofit.

So, what exactly is Donor Retention Rate? It’s all about understanding how well you’re maintaining relationships with your donors. Rather than focusing solely on acquiring new donors, this metric emphasizes the importance of keeping the ones you already have engaged and committed to your cause.

Why is this so important? Well, retaining existing donors is far more cost-effective than acquiring new ones. According to the Association of Fundraising Professionals (AFP) and the Center on Nonprofits and Philanthropy at the Urban Institute's Fundraising Effectiveness Project report, it costs significantly less to retain a donor than to attract a new one. High retention rates are a strong indicator of donor satisfaction and loyalty, meaning your supporters believe in your mission and trust your organization to make an impact.

Let’s break down how to calculate this metric. To find your Donor Retention Rate, you must determine the number of donors who gave last year, who also gave this year, then divide that number by the number of donors who gave last year, then multiply by 100 to get a percentage.

Here’s an example. Suppose you had 800 donors last year, and out of those, 600 donated again this year. To calculate the Donor Retention Rate, you divide 600 by 800, which equals 0.75. Multiply that by 100, and you get a 75% retention rate. This means that 75% of your donors from last year decided to continue supporting your organization.

The AFP and the Fundraising Effectiveness Project highlight this metric because of its direct correlation with the long-term success and sustainability of nonprofits. Organizations with higher retention rates typically see more stable funding streams, allowing them to plan and execute long-term projects more effectively.

Understanding your Donor Retention Rate offers several benefits. First, it gives you insights into the strength of your donor relationships. A high retention rate suggests that your donors are happy with the way you’re engaging them and feel their contributions are making a difference. It’s a clear signal that your communication, stewardship, and engagement strategies are working.

Second, focusing on donor retention can lead to more effective use of resources. Since it’s more cost-effective to retain existing donors than to acquire new ones, investing in retention strategies can yield higher returns. Personalized communication, regular updates on impact, and meaningful thank-you notes are all part of a robust retention strategy.

Finally, a strong Donor Retention Rate can help build a more committed and passionate donor base. Donors who give year after year are more likely to increase their contributions over time and become advocates for your cause, bringing in new supporters through word-of-mouth.

So, as you plan your fundraising strategies, make sure you’re paying close attention to your Donor Retention Rate. It’s more than just a metric; it’s a reflection of the trust and satisfaction your donors have in your organization. By focusing on retaining your donors, you can build a solid foundation for sustained growth and long-term success.

Alright, Ambitious Fundraisers, as a special bonus, let's talk about an often overlooked but incredibly vital metric: Visitation and Engagement Metrics. This one’s all about tracking the number of contacts you have with a donor as they progress through the pipeline toward making a major gift.

So, what exactly are Visitation and Engagement Metrics? Essentially, this metric measures every meaningful touchpoint you have with a donor—whether it's a phone call, a face-to-face meeting, an email exchange, or a discussion at an event. It’s about understanding how often and how effectively you’re engaging with your donors.

Why is this important? Well, as we discussed when talking about the number of Asks Made, most major gift donors don’t make a gift immediately after your first contact with them. Building strong, trusting relationships takes time and multiple engagements. By tracking these visits and engagements, you can establish an optimal contact schedule and improve your donor engagement strategies.

Let’s dive into the details. Imagine you’re working on cultivating a potential major donor. Your first step might be a phone call to introduce yourself and your organization. Next, you might schedule a face-to-face meeting to discuss their interests and how they align with your mission. Following that, you might send a few personalized emails sharing stories of impact or updates on specific projects they might find compelling. Each of these interactions is a touchpoint that brings the donor closer to making a significant contribution.

Now, let’s break this down with an example. Suppose you have a donor who you’ve identified as a potential major gift contributor. Over six months, you’ve had three phone calls, two in-person meetings, five email exchanges, and a few casual discussions at events. By keeping track of these touchpoints, you can see how engaged the donor is and identify patterns that lead to successful major gift asks.

Visitation and Engagement Metrics help you understand how these interactions build over time to create a strong relationship. It’s not just about the quantity but also the quality of these engagements. Substantive contacts—like in-depth meetings or personalized emails—are more impactful than unsubstantive ones, such as a quick hello at an event.

Tracking this metric offers several benefits. First, it helps you establish an optimal contact schedule. By analyzing which types of engagements lead to successful donations, you can refine your strategies to focus on what works best. Second, it provides insights into donor behavior. You can see how different donors respond to various types of engagements and tailor your approach accordingly.

Finally, keeping detailed records of your visits and engagements ensures you’re building a robust pipeline for those major gift asks. You’re not just making a one-time ask; you’re cultivating a relationship that could lead to ongoing support and significant contributions over time.

So, as you work on your major gift strategies, remember the importance of Visitation and Engagement Metrics. They’re more than just numbers; they’re a roadmap to building strong, lasting relationships with your donors. By understanding and leveraging these metrics, you can ensure you’re engaging your donors effectively and setting the stage for successful major gift asks.

And there you have it, Ambitious Fundraisers—the top 10 most important fundraising metrics, plus our special bonus metric! Let’s quickly recap the metrics we’ve discussed and their significance in boosting your fundraising efforts.

At number 10, we started with Cost Per Dollar Raised (CPDR), highlighting the importance of understanding the cost efficiency of your fundraising activities. Number 9 was Donation Revenue Growth Rate, a key indicator of your overall fundraising growth. Coming in at number 8, we looked at Average and Median Gift Size, crucial for understanding donor generosity and guiding segmentation strategies.

Number 7, Asks Made, reminded us of the importance of tracking how many direct requests for contributions you make. At number 6, Major Gifts Secured showed us the value and quantity of large donations, essential for meeting your fundraising goals. Number 5, Fundraising Return on Investment (ROI), helped us measure the efficiency of our fundraising efforts by comparing the amount raised to the cost.

At number 4, Recurring Gift Percentage highlighted the importance of regular donations and financial stability. Number 3, Lifetime Donor Value (LTV), provided insights into the long-term value of donor relationships. Number 2, Donor Acquisition Rate, showed how well we’re attracting new supporters.

Finally, at number 1, Donor Retention Rate underscored the importance of keeping your donors engaged and loyal, a critical aspect for any sustainable fundraising strategy.

And don’t forget our bonus metric, Visitation and Engagement Metrics. Tracking your substantive and unsubstantive contacts with donors ensures you’re building strong relationships and effectively managing your donor pipeline for major gift asks.

Tracking these metrics isn’t just about numbers; it’s about understanding the heartbeat of your organization’s fundraising efforts. By paying close attention to these metrics, you can refine your strategies, improve your outcomes, and ultimately make a bigger impact.

I encourage you to start tracking these metrics if you aren’t already. Use them to guide your decisions, celebrate your successes, and identify areas for improvement. They’re powerful tools that can help you build stronger relationships with your donors and drive your mission forward.

Thanks for joining me on this deep dive into fundraising metrics. Be sure to tune in to the next episode of Let’s Talk Fundraising, where we’ll share more insights on effective fundraising practices and how you can take your strategies to the next level.

Until next time, keep making a difference, and remember—you have the power to transform your organization and the lives of those you serve. Happy fundraising!